in English exist on
this subject. Maulana Sayyid Muhammad Rizvi is the compiler of a book
containing several very interesting articles relating to the history of the
tragedy of Karbala’. Then there is Shaykh Mufid (A.R.)'s al Irshad.
Extrapolations of certain inferences from known facts are not, in my opinion or
in the opinion of the 'ulema, objectionable. For example description of natural
human emotions, though not chronicled in vivid detail may be extrapolated if
the description is within the bounds of reason and does not detract from the character
of the personalities involved.
Some of the maqaatil can be faulted in respect of certain statements For
example Tabari records that the age of Imam Zain-ul-'Abideen (A.S.) was
questioned at Kufa and he was examined to determine whether he had attained
buloogh. (See the History of al Tabari, Vol. XIX page 166). Shaykh Mufid gives
the fourth Imam's age at the time as 23 years. It is well known the Imam was
married and had a son.
Many such contradictions exist in the maqaatil but this does not mean that we
have to reject any account in total. Detailed events, and often the names of
those involved, are very difficult to record accurately even by an honest and
meticulous chronicler recording contemporaneously as the events are taking
place. Abu Mikhnaf began to compile his history, mostly through eye witness
account at least twenty five years after the tragedy. It is necessary for us to
be eclectic for so long as we remain within the confines of reason. To be
eclectic we must know what historical material is available and where to find
it.
It is not within the scope of this article to deal with all the historical
sources I would refer the reader to S. H. M, Jafri's the Origins and Early
Development of Shi'a Islam, Chapter 7. I would also refer any reader interested
in the subject to the following additional works:
1. The volume of Tabari referred to above.
2. Al-Irshad by Shaykh Mufid.
3. The article by Imam Husayn by Veccia Vaglieri in the Encyclopaedia of Islam
which is based mostly Balaadhuri's account.
Objectives
We have to remember that the 'ashra al-Muharram is a very emotional period and
this emotion has to be exploited by the ahle minabir to convey the message of
Karbala’, to awaken a hatred against all that Yazid stood for and to rekindle a
commitment to Islam as preached by the Ahlul Bayt and for which Imam Husayn
laid down his life.
We can not perpetuate the illusion that Aza’ al-Husayn means no more than a few
tears, matam and processions. These are the means and not the end. They are
important only if they lead each of us becoming a better Shiah than we were in
the preceding year.
If we lose sight of the objectives we may find ourselves answerable for
forgetting and holding to ridicule the cause for which our Imam sacrificed so
much!
Imam Husayn himself advised a muslim who was claiming to be a shiah to fear
Allah and not to make a false claim lest on the Day of Judgement he is raised
with the liars. “Our shiah,” the Imam added, “is the one whose heart is pure of
malice, deception and corruption. His words and deeds are only for the pleasure
of Allah.”
We must during this forthcoming 'ashra al-Muharram pose this question to
ourselves in all seriousness. Do we intend to make a commitment to Imam
Husayn's objectives or do we wish to continue complacently in our current
state, paying what can best be described a lip service to his martyrdom with
demonstrative mourning only??
While I pray that we begin, as we must, to understand the philosophy of Aza’
al-Husayn and make a serious commitment to the objectives of the King of
Martyrs, I sincerely hope that there never comes a day when majaalis are
replaced by clinical lectures devoid of all emotion! Reason when supported by
emotion has a more enduring effect, and it is for this very end that as a
recompense of the rationality of the message of the Holy Prophet he is told by
Allah to ask for no recompense save the love of Ahlul Bayt. Love, while being
an emotional force, becomes hypocrisy if one fails to identify and follow the
wishes of the loved one.
May all our Muharrams be true demonstration of our love for, and a confluence
of emotion, reason and commitment to, Imam Husayn.
References
1. Kitab al-Irshad by Shaykh al Mufid
2. The History of Tabari, the English translation, Vol. XIX
3. The Rising of al-Husayn by Shaykh Muhammad Mahdi Shams al-Deen
4. Imam Husayn, the Saviour of Islam by Maulana Sayyid Muhammad Rizvi
5. Al-Serat the Imam Husayn Conference Number, published by the Muhammadi
Trust, July 1984
6. The origins and Early Development of Shi'a Islam, by S. H. M. Jafri
7. Al-Tawhid, Vol. II No. 1, the Editorial.
8. Al Tawhid, Vol. XIII, No. 3, Pages 41 to 74, reproducing the article by
Martyr Murtadha Mutaharri entitled “Ashura : History and Popular Legend”
9. The History of Azadari published by Peermahomed Trust
10. The last issue of Jafferi News